Rewriting the Rules of the Hunt: Is Vermont Getting It Wrong?
By: Kaleb Brown
By: Kaleb Brown
On the eve of Vermont’s regular bow season, which traditionally starts on October 1st, I usually feel the “night before Christmas” rush. This year, things are a little different.
Growing up in New England, the fall was always marked by the changing leaves and rumblings of hunting season coming. I spent the season traveling to as many New England states as time and tags allowed. From archery season in Vermont to rifle season in New Hampshire, to late-season muzzleloader hunting in Massachusetts, I was and still am on the move, planning my seasons around goals for that given year and what time allows.
After a successful 2025 deer season, I started to think, what will my 2026 goals be? See as many states as possible? Fill the freezer to help offset the rising cost of groceries? Search far and wide for a “non-typical” buck with an abstract set of antlers?
These thoughts were heavy on my mind until I saw a Facebook post from Vermont Fish & Wildlife discussing new changes coming for deer season in 2026. The post led me to the Vermont Fish & Wildlife website’s White-Tailed Deer page, which laid out what will be new for the 2026 season.
Let’s talk about the good, the bad, and the ugly.

The state implemented an early expanded archery season, meaning that for the first time ever, hunters can hunt in designated zones from September 15-30 for antlerless deer (does) only. This is a huge win for conservation. All of these expanded areas fall into one of two categories: urban zones where the deer population is booming and the islands of Lake Champlain, Zone A. This expansion creates an excellent opportunity to help control deer herds to a healthier population and gives hunters a chance to harvest a deer before the regular season starts. I participated in the expanded archery season with some of my close friends, and we all had two great weeks of hunting. We all saw deer, and a few of us were lucky enough to harvest mature does.
It is great to see the state taking conservation-minded steps towards a healthier and more sustainable deer herd. However, things become a little questionable with the next new laws for 2026.

While many New England states are similar in habitat and food sources, some states allow you to take two bucks in a season, such as Massachusetts. Deer density varies heavily throughout the Northeast, but historically, many New England states have some of the lowest deer densities in the country. With large stands of timber, big woods, and low deer density, hunting can be extremely challenging.
For the first time, Vermont is allowing hunters to harvest two antlered deer in the same calendar year. There are two stipulations before one is allowed to harvest a second buck: they must harvest an antlerless deer and harvest a first buck that has a minimum of three points on one side. In theory, the opportunity to obtain a second buck tag should decrease the number of smaller bucks taken overall, allowing bucks more time to reach a mature age as hunters pass on harvesting one smaller buck for the chance at a larger one. However, it will allow for the overall deer take to be higher. More bucks will be harvested in total, and the next rule change will certainly have more people hitting the antlerless deer requirement. Can the herd support this extra take?
For the first time since the 1979-1981 season, the state will allow the harvest of antlerless deer during rifle season, which was initially instituted due to “overpopulation.” This one raises eyebrows for many. Rifle season has the highest participation of any season here in Vermont and typically accounts for 40-45% of all deer harvested. While the state has decreased the number of Antlerless Permits overall for this season (only 12,050 compared to the 23,400 in 2025, a stark 49% decrease) to hopefully lower the number of does taken, it raises a few concerns among many local hunters, myself included.
8,065 antlerless deer were harvested last year in Vermont, and annual harvests are typically in the high 7,000s range. This year, with the number of participants, we will likely see the highest number of antlerless deer harvested since the late 70s and early 80s. I have had the privilege of knowing some true “old timers” here in Vermont and have picked their brains about this hot topic. Every one of them has made the same point: “Why do you think they stopped after only three years?” It was a huge hit to the herd. Harvest numbers plummeted for years and have taken a long time to come up to what they are today.
While the early archery expansion is a genuine win for the herd, the second and third changes (antlerless deer being legal again during rifle season, on top of a potential second buck being taken) are the ones that have me watching closely. The state is clearly trying to thread the needle: grow the herd through conservation-minded moves while still managing overpopulation where it exists. I respect the intent. But history has a way of repeating itself if we’re not careful, and the numbers from ’79 to ’83 aren’t just old statistics to the hunters who lived through them; they’re a cautionary tale.
With roughly 4,000 more antlerless tags potentially eligible during rifle season, plus the added pressure of a second buck tag in play, my concern isn’t that the state is wrong to try; it’s whether our herd can absorb that kind of pressure without hunter success rates taking a serious hit. A healthier herd long-term is the goal we all want. I just don’t want us to find out the hard way that we moved too fast to get there.
My 2026 goal is simple. Stick it out in Vermont this year. Keep a firsthand pulse on it. Hunt through archery, rifle, and muzzleloader season, talk with as many hunters as I can, and watch closely to see what these changes actually do to harvest reports and the herd in the years ahead. Time will tell, but for now, all eyes are on the numbers.